Monday, November 11, 2013

Prince Naveen and His Race, Or, Lack Thereof


After spending the last 30 minutes browsing the interwebs and exploring the question of Prince Naveen's racial ambiguity, I have come to the conclusion that the world will never know what race Naveen is supposed to represent. The more important question to consider then, is if this was an ingenious decision on Disney's part or rather a self-incriminating one. Though I failed to find any solid evidence from the Walt Disney Company itself or any extremely compelling arguments for one race over the other, I did happen upon a large number of various articles, blog posts, and journals criticizing one facet or another of Naveen's race. Like Ajay Gehlawat asserts in "The Strange Case of The Princess and the Frog: Passing and the Elision of Race", Naveen encompasses physical and linguistic traits that associate him with both India and France, two cultures that are indisputably different. 

Why did Disney feel the need to do this? Naveen's character is an artistic decision that I may never get over because I am just so perplexed as to why Disney consciously crafted him to be the way that he is. Though I have little evidence, which I believe was a purposeful maneuver by Disney to keep Naveen's racial identity as ambiguous as possible, I too will add my voice to the masses and speculate as to why Naveen essentially possesses "no race". No matter how much I thought about it, it just did not make logical sense to me that Disney would purposefully conceive such an obscure prince-- but then I realized that this obscurity was the point.

By refusing to categorize Naveen, Disney is able to get closer to achieving the paradoxically race-representing and race-blind film that it so desires. By confusing the audience enough over the topic of race through Naveen, Disney is able to mold The Princess and the Frog to address both those who believe that race is represented positively and those who believe that race is represented negatively in the film. It is a phenomenon that, at least for me, warrants enough bewilderment that, after intensively trying to discover an answer and failing, I have no choice but to let it be. It would be interesting to view Disney's true motive behind creating this film. My guess is that they felt pressured to encompass diversity in their films, and didn't know how to go about it in a "politically correct" manner that would appeal to their target audience. Thus, Naveen was born out of their desire to at once introduce "Otherness" but also adhere to the traditional European princes that are known to sell to the public. 

What do you think about the fact that Naveen strikingly resembles, to put it in Gehlawat's terms, an "extremely brown" Eric from The Little Mermaid? I, for one, am utterly mystified. 

20 comments:

  1. I also thought this was a very interesting topic. I felt it was smart for Disney to depict Naveen as raceless. If Naveen's race is unknown, then the issue of racism can't be brought up. The point of the movie is to show that race doesn't matter, so Naveen's race should not make a difference in the love story.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree that it was strategic of Disney to make Naveen's race so ambiguous. If no one can say for sure what race he is, it's impossible for anyone to say that Disney is guilty of racial stereotyping. I love the fact that you pointed out that Naveen resembles "an extremely brown" Eric; I had never noticed that before! Could that be an attempt by Disney to make Naveen seem similar to princes of past Disney films in order to make Naveen more immediately accepted? Either way, I think this is a great starting point for Disney and I hope that as more diversified films come out they will start to characterize the princes and princesses in ways that don't make their race a non-factor.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I can't believe there are people out there that are actually angry about this lol I always thought naveen was supposed to be some sort of hispanic, middle eastern, even caucus sort of mix lol why anyone would be angry that he isn't black is beyond me.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Shut up bitch,stop trying to make everything you don't know "hispanic".

      Delete
    2. Same I'm a latino female and this man looks like a lot of he people that comes from my home island. I always thought he was some sort of hispanic latino, he even has an accent of a romance language.

      Delete
    3. Hispanic is not a race, dumbass. The reason for why he resembles the people from your home island is because latin america's racial background is black, white, indigenous, asian...... Could be anything. His voice is from a brazilian man, but that doesn't mean he's brazilian either.

      Delete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I doubt most people were angry lol. That's just silly. Perhaps a little let down. I personally think it would've been cool to see a black prince represented just like other Disney princes were.

    ReplyDelete
  6. People fail to realize that are different black people all of the world. He doesn't have to be African American. I always thought he was a French black man. Plus Ik that many people in New Orleans speech French or are French. So yes he could b a French black man

    ReplyDelete
  7. People fail to realize that are different black people all of the world. He doesn't have to be African American. I always thought he was a French black man. Plus Ik that many people in New Orleans speech French or are French. So yes he could b a French black man

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. He's not french... he knew French because he is a prince and they are expected to know more than one language.

      Delete
    2. DUDE. no one knows his race... thats what this post is trying to explain.. yes ppl do forget about the French-Black ppl( I have friends like that) but thats not the issue.. An
      yways i like how positive this comment section is

      Delete
  8. He's half indian, i guess. Bc of his name(which is an Indian name) and in the end of the movie his mother was wearing a saree.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Is it confirmed that she's wearing a sari? It's possible that it's a sash like the one Navine and his dad are wearing. Why is he "half" Indian? Couldnt his dad be Indian too?

      Delete
    2. the comment said his mother is most likely the indian one because the character is portrayed as mix-raced

      Delete
  9. y'all don't get it? the reason ppl r mad is because we had one chance to have a Black Prince and Disney refused to see a Black man in such a position of prominence...we have one princess of each race .....however there r multiple white princes n princesses....

    ReplyDelete
  10. If you weren't saying "race shouldn't be an issue" when studios casted black men in stereotypically violent and uncivil ways,as they typically have done, then you sound unreasonable to say "I don't know who would be mad at this."

    ReplyDelete
  11. Prince Naveen is Indian to some degree. Only because Naveen is an Indian name. His mother also happens to wear a saree and Indian jewelry and plus his skin colour....?

    ReplyDelete
  12. He is just white enough so that the white girl can have a crush on him, and judge brown enough so that the “white genocide” folks can put aside their foolishness for a while. Just a little clarification: while real genocide is unspeakable violence and death on a massive scale, “white genocide” is just good loving and pretty babies.

    ReplyDelete
  13. His mother wore a saree also he has a Sanskrit name so he is half indian

    ReplyDelete